Make: 2015 3D Printer Shoot Out Test Geometries

Make Magazine's third annual 3D Printing Shootout was conducted using these files, designed by Andreas Bastain (www.andreasbastian.com), to benchmark performance of desktop 3D printers.

Education

    Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike

    Commercial use is allowed, you must attribute the creator, you may remix this work and the remixed work should be made available under this license.

    Learn more or download attribution tags

    Description

    Read all 26 machine reviews in Make:'s Annual Guide to 3D Printing 2015: http://bit.ly/1E9zk17


    These test geometries are designed to evaluate specific performance characteristics and motion systems in common low-cost FDM/FFF machines. Traditionally, layer height has been used as a proxy for resolution or quality, but it is a bit of an oversimplification of what is often termed "print quality". The following test geometries individually probe very specific aspects of 3D printer performance in an effort to develop a parametric and quantitative definition of 3D printer quality. 

     One of the exciting aspects of sharing a standard set of test geometries is that everybody can share their results and learn from this pool of results.  Please post images of individual test geometries printed on your machines using the "I Made One" feature and include your *slicer, layer height, shells, temperature, and print time.

     Additionally, the test geometries were modeled in Fusion 360 and are designed to be easily modified easily using a small set of control parameters. Source files (.f3d) can be found in the zipped "FDM_f3d.zip" folder.



    Here's how to evaluate and score these test prints: http://wp.me/p22K2I-1TOt




    Prints:

    1. Dimensional Accuracy

    2. Bridging Performance

    3. Overhang Performance

    4. Negative Space Tolerance

    5. Fine Positive Features Performance

    6. XY Resonance

    7. Z Resonance

    Documents

    Issues

    Issues are used to track todos, bugs or requests. To get started, you could create an issue.

    Comments

    7f746f3fe4c3f7bdd0d014185e823348?default=blank&size=40Steven added this to the Tools collection ago
    2a39bdde9dc4d70bca7f6a57ff33476a?default=blank&size=40Mehrböd Man printed this ago
    Carousel thumb dsc09898
    Printed on:
    Ultimaker - The Ultimaker 2
    Result:
    That was fine, to behinest I didn't expect ood shape for first print but that was fine. I tried twice and for second try I rotate the bridge. But the the shape of Brise wasn't nice like the orinal possition.
    Mini 1Dubai Bunnies added this to the Print collection ago
    Mini anool 03Anool Mahidharia added this to the UM2_to_print collection ago
    73b090bbb30b82ff3598f118b45181b8?default=blank&size=40Zepco added this to the Drukarka 3D collection ago
    21ff19c0488b08a28be70e955dc08cb1?default=blank&size=40Jon Filteau added this to the Things to Print collection ago
    D9bce968fee59bc41f8fb44c9ddf4c36?default=blank&size=40Erik Avery added this to the Calibration collection ago
    Cc08ffa669f01f88c5864727d98fa191?default=blank&size=40nilrog added this to the Testfiles collection ago
    979b09aca74ba3c7804f3877ab5d8ee4?default=blank&size=40Robert Allison added this to the to make collection ago
    3058249a74a60499ccb196f8c95a226b?default=blank&size=40Dimmstone added this to the 1 collection ago
    8a5c44b7373dbc273f779d0c0a949129?default=blank&size=40Arvin Orena added this to the test collection ago
    B90381919477063622341ca08bc6f070?default=blank&size=40qbnflaco added this to the To Print collection ago
    Mini 11754397 10206328150656315 4100330236590689548 obortek added this to the UM2 collection ago
    99e66d0bd6f30b25346f80609631dd05?default=blank&size=40Ara Yapejian added this to the Calibration collection ago
    F86433246d83ca9e6814fb5a78455820?default=blank&size=40b3london added this to the Print Later collection ago
    De2e62e8d80ba6c81fb1deb952ce700e?default=blank&size=40derFonz added this to the 3D test and calibration collection ago
    86cfe30bc48e6cd2ce28eabd771cd974?default=blank&size=40suederi added this to the Tools collection ago
    264804c264c394b648f0455983f94155?default=blank&size=40Chris Jornlin added this to the Things to make collection ago
    37a9c5e05a26d97ed08a8486de2546c5?default=blank&size=40jocampo added this to the Things to try collection ago
    Mini skewd rgb 01skewdesigndevelop added this to the to print collection ago
    7537793f5f443aac354b669704b21d26?default=blank&size=40dreamy added this to the Thing to Make collection ago
    F511f9acc61ef49005dcf4e96661be4e?default=blank&size=40Frank Spina added this to the To Make collection ago
    6482f1269e98b03f37127df3882792f8?default=blank&size=40Thurm added this to the Tests / Calibrations collection ago
    36660e7f0b122141f93f8e09f0c33439?default=blank&size=40Fabricio Clariano added this to the Printer collection ago
    42230503dbb1346fb96e836316ee7b6d?default=blank&size=40botschke added this to the JB Druck Liste collection ago
    E59da6e4c79c94363429c9cc1f9c2765?default=blank&size=40m42e added this to the tests collection ago
    58bd99949b36b31d0a20cf641a023586?default=blank&size=40Alexander Davidson added this to the Calibration collection ago
    Fcb3469695c95a5e23c2429eaae67447?default=blank&size=40Adam Rękosiewicz added this to the tests collection ago
    0e69e5e5da671d2d875e8d22949b904d?default=blank&size=40Buj commented ago

    Has anyone setup a form to allow data evaluation/comparison?

    094aac0ffb6150e3cfc7b496fa1fae9c?default=blank&size=40Mastereye added this to the Um Upgrade collection ago
    A3a00d3356b4370df03b4a075d7f3dc4?default=blank&size=40jbkoffel added this to the To Print collection ago
    2aa95e75c66a1421816c53f94514223c?default=blank&size=40Thirkell added this to the My Prusa i3 collection ago
    Mini yves profile picYves Tilkin added this to the Test print collection ago
    D08993daec78724d920b5b8e8257e00f?default=blank&size=40Doomish added this to the Calibration collection ago
    3c0777fa30af7a3791da326ea3e25d58?default=blank&size=40bilsch added this to the test suites collection ago
    Ccf8c4b10b1c29ff74ab0f6794983050?default=blank&size=40fvitte added this to the Boulot collection ago
    297087dbc1c69530b116a9740431cbc2?default=blank&size=40Hugo Luquis added this to the Printer collection ago
    0cfc9ba6b308ef464701d80fc5c85948?default=blank&size=40nattlesnake added this to the YES collection ago
    A6bf4809dca7883359b2c2b3fa6b1432?default=blank&size=40jbrede added this to the SmartCore collection ago
    72059b636281a712afca4abe98a17899?default=blank&size=40sfouche added this to the Calibration collection ago
    140ad02ae13e519b4c6a6ea53928d614?default=blank&size=40csbroc00 added this to the New collection ago
    7880ada895046128458cc6a001771e89?default=blank&size=40Tatertot444 added this to the Calibration collection ago
    29e420375c0441efd861fbe20925e8ed?default=blank&size=40vrillusions added this to the Calibration and Testing collection ago
    A0210305b0be103ecd872bb9761071e9?default=blank&size=40ezhookup added this to the Calibration collection ago
    Mini headshotBrad Vaughan added this to the Calibration collection ago
    Mini photo  4 Droopas added this to the Stress test collection ago
    A3be5e022a181dff58738a08fd7f1555?default=blank&size=40aieie added this to the test collection ago
    69adc8990515124deee8340415ccfaac?default=blank&size=40Matt LaRussa added this to the Printer Calibration collection ago
    Mini lisca mangaLisca added this to the Calibration collection ago
    Fd77be238c23a2e25eddbd8fb12d5360?default=blank&size=40yansiegers added this to the Test objects collection ago
    Mini 3davatarPaulo Rodrigues added this to the Calibration Tools collection ago
    2b6f4d2d0973bed25b8b511f81f18163?default=blank&size=40Willem Gerber added this to the Calibration Test collection ago
    3da49e5f162182fd3caf735ba7db70a3?default=blank&size=40Louis Garcia added this to the A faire collection ago
    672dd54da5ede1417aa71f14c2e4a909?default=blank&size=40BillyM added this to the calibration collection ago
    14a08fe1bbcf74ecb8e48d00db6130e8?default=blank&size=40thebeast added this to the Test prints collection ago
    A82a0697d3dc8105bfb3829489e744ad?default=blank&size=40Joescottii added this to the Calibration collection ago
    E2fd9076e2bfd827e6f9c75e98007911?default=blank&size=40wcmartino added this to the Stuff collection ago
    804d6c66f4b416deb68d9a6431570008?default=blank&size=40jasonoy added this to the UM collection ago
    Mini monkeymeLyle LeBlanc added this to the Tests collection ago
    3d64913729af00844f753847bf291bc4?default=blank&size=40r3xx0n added this to the Testdrucke collection ago
    054759125285d9ad5f56414b9a1ca00c?default=blank&size=40Zac Yap added this to the new collection ago
    E59a63e4a70c7ef90f9ab0eeefa8e906?default=blank&size=40Shro added this to the À faire collection ago
    Cb013efa08026866713ee8ea4f98a733?default=blank&size=40Sergey Fedorov added this to the Test 3D Printers collection ago
    0833769924c3baf9865b290c98ca53e5?default=blank&size=40MakerDom added this to the Things to make collection ago
    B7d6f1119e8b887805ec65ee991f1401?default=blank&size=40lucaslaboratories added this to the Things to Make collection ago
    7132a5b72a1be56000406b297b99106c?default=blank&size=40Dizzee Jones added this to the 3D Printer collection ago
    650e2a3fcec16d037c413a47579bffd5?default=blank&size=40Camarinha added this to the Geral collection ago
    Mini aimeeprofileavatarAimeethyst added this to the Interesting Things collection ago
    Mini laura creepermathgrrl added this to the Nice collection ago
    Mini frederiekFrederiek Pascal added this to the things to make collection ago
    3da65402371bd0ffe7b5006d4bed05a2?default=blank&size=40Angela Northcutt added this to the To make collection ago
    Mini meJoris Peels added this to the Useful Test Print Pieces collection ago
    Mini mark.g.peeters.4.23.14Peetersm printed this ago
    Carousel thumb retract3 blobs fine feature test
    Printed on:
    Ultimaker Original+
    Result:
    The stringing was not bad, but I am getting blobs (at retraction points) anyone else seeing this?
    Feedback:
    OK I was able to greatly reduce the stringing by setting Minimal extrusion before retracting = 0 These pictures show the blobs I think are due to retractions, current settings: FINE FEATURES TEST PRINT layer height 0.2mm shell 0.8mm fill 20% print speed 50mm/s temp 200 retract speed 35mm/s retract distance 5.5mm travel speed 250mm/s retract-Minimal travel 1.5mm retract-enable comb=off retract-minimal extrusion before retracting 0mm retract-zhop 0mm
    6f3142618c76cdca63a7216b90dff423?default=blank&size=40Greg42 commented ago

    For the accuracy/backlash test, I suggest that people report the measured length of the diameter in the X direction and the Y direction so that there will be a clear picture of where different people's results differ.


    Please remember to list:1. Filament source2. Print time since slower printing may increase the quality of a print3. Software settings used such as layer height, nozzle temperature and quality mode.

    Mini make logo2Make Magazine published this design ago